Mechanical Edits/Math1985 mechanical/Several Dutch chain shops
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
This edit has been executed on 1 January 2016.
Proposal
I propose to unify the shop tag for several Dutch chain shops. The proposed changes are listed in the following table.
Name | Current tags | Proposed tag | Comments |
---|---|---|---|
Etos | 473x shop=chemist, 6x shop=convenience | shop=chemist | |
Kruidvat | 244x shop=chemist, 26x shop=convenience, 5x shop=supermarket | shop=chemist | |
Shoeby | 29x shop=clothes, 9x shop=shoes | shop=clothes | Confusion probably caused by the name. |
Zeeman | 122x shop=clothes, 6x shop=textile, 5x shop=convenience | shop=clothes | shop=textile is not commonly used or supported by data consumers |
Kwantum | 17x shop=furniture, 9x shop=doityourself, 5x shop=interior_decoration | shop=furniture | I would rather see Kwantum as a furniture business than a interior decoration business. They also sell things for decoration, but these are rather accessories for the furniture. |
Manfield | 24x shop=shoes, 7x shop=clothes | shop=shoes | Shoes are the core business |
Scapino | 26x shop=shoes, 19x shop=clothes | shop=shoes | Shoes are the core business |
Albert Heijn to go | 20x shop=supermarket, 18x shop=convenience | shop=convenience | Proposal does not correspond to current practice, but Albert Heijn to go is a prototypical convenience shop. |
Action | 41x shop=variety_store, 9x shop=convenience | shop=variety_store | |
Big Bazar | 13x shop=variety_store, 9x shop=department_store, 5x shop=convenience | shop=variety_store |
An overview of affected shops in the Netherlands can be found through Overpass Turbo: http://overpass-turbo.eu/s/dqb
Rationale
The retail chains in this proposal have often been tagged with incorrect shop tags. Correcting the shop tags make the data more useful to data consumers.
I will take the following measurements to guarantee community support and minimize the risk of incorrect edits:
- I will follow, of course, the Automated Edits code of conduct.
- I have created the current page to document this automatic edit.
- I have discussed this edit at the 'users: Netherlands' forum (link).
Technical implementation
- I will use JOSM combined with Overpass.
- I will download the data from Overpass, and manually select the Netherlands only. Subsequently, I will change the shop tag to the proposed tag, and upload the data.
- I will do this edit in one changeset per chain with tags "mechanical=yes" and "comment=Correct shop tag, see https://wiki.openstreetmap.org/w/index.php?title=Mechanical_Edits/Math1985_mechanical/Several_Dutch_chain_shops".
- This is expected to be a one-time edit. If the need arises for a new round of mass renaming, this will be discussed with the community again.
- I will allow users to opt-out. If users want me not to touch some objects, they can contact me in the forum or by e-mail. No opt-outs have been received.
Contact
Matthijs Melissen, osm@matthijsmelissen.nl